| Three-Time All-Americans | All-Americans |
| Kevin Donahue (2004, 2006-07) | Andrew Bogle (1996) |
| Two-Time All-Americans | Kirk Adamson (2003) |
| Zach Rolfe (2005-06) | Thomas Hovis (2004) |
| Tyler Hamblin (2006-07) | Hunter MacDonald (2005) |
| Tyler Spangler (2007-08) | Tim Rose (2005) |
| Ted Gottwald (2009-10) | Ashton Gilmore (2006) |
| Loren Phillips (2009-10) | Jackson Freeman (2009) |
| David Wesley (2009-10)* | Chris Gill (2009) |
| Brandon Jeske (2010)* | |
| *Active wrestler for 2010-11 season |
| Four-Time Champions | State Champions |
| Kevin Donahue (2004-07) | Robert Kirkman (1973) |
| Three-Time Champions | Lake Taylor (1988) |
| Robbie Fiero (1988-90) | Jimmy Sanderson (1989) |
| David Hicks (1999-01) | Gordon Lewis (1989) |
| Zach Rolfe (2004-06) | Latane Frank (1990) |
| Tyler Hamblin (2005-07) | Jacob Moore (1994) |
| Tyler Spangler (2007-09) | Chaffriax Lelong (1996) |
| Ted Gottwald (2008-10) | Peyton Studebaker (1998) |
| Two-Time Champions | Jimmy Hovis (1999) |
| Andrew Bogle (1996-97) | Burton Fuller (2001) |
| Brian McGurk (2001-02) | Akel Grantham (2002) |
| Brian Herod (2003-04) | Jeb Pinkerton (2003) |
| David Schafer (2004-05) | Tyler Schmidt (2003) |
| Hunter MacDonald (2004-05) | Ryan Robertson (2004) |
| Tyler Schmidt (2003, 2005) | Josh Moses (2005) |
| Craig Phillip (2006-07) | Sam Redd (2005) |
| Joseph Munno (2006-07) | Tim Rose (2005) |
| Ashton Gilmore (2006) | |
| Clarke Gottwald (2008) | |
| Kevin Issacs (2008) | |
| Mark Burlee (2009) | |
| Loren Phillips (2010) | |
| Chris Gill (2010) | |
| David Wesley (2010)* | |
Brandon Jeske (2010)* |
Here is a list of St. Christopher's All-State Wrestlers from 1996-2010. This is a work in progress. If you have State results prior to 1996, please email them to Coach Prebish. Wrestlers listed in bold will be active for the 2010-11 wrestling season.
Five-Time State Place Winners:
| Zach Rolfe | 02-06 | 5-3-1-1-1 |
Four-Time State Place Winners:
Ryan Robertson 01-04 5-3-4-1 Brian Herod 01-04 5-4-1-1 Hunter Carpenter 00-03 6-2-3-5 Hunter Macdonald 02-05 5-3-1-1 Kevin Donahue 04-07 1-1-1-1 Tyler Hamblen 04-07 2-1-1-1 Ted Gottwald 07-10 3-1-1-1 Loren Phillips 07-10 5-2-2-1 David Wesley 07-10 3-2-2-1
Three-Time State Place Winners:
Jim Clary 96-98 6-2-3 Asher Rolfe 97-99 2-6-2 Dave Hicks 98-00 1-1-1 Jimmy Hovis 98-00 5-1-2 Kirk Adamson 02-04 3-2-3 Thomas Hovis 02-04 3-2-3 Joseph Munno 05-07 2-1-1 Clark Gottwald 06-08 3-2-1 Tyler Spangler 07-09 1-1-1 Rennie Merhige 08-10 3-2-2
Two-Time State Place Winners:
Charlie Moore 99-00 4-5 Andrew Bogle 96-97 1-1 Burton Fuller 00-01 6-1 Brian McGurk 01-02 1-1 Jeb Pinkerton 02-03 2-1 Brandon Nunnally 03,05 5-2 Tyler Schmidt 03,05 1-1 David Schafer 04-05 1-1 Josh Moses 04-05 6-1 Sam Redd 04-05 4-1 Tim Rose 04-05 5-1 Craig Philip 06-07 1-1 Matt Talbott 06-07 4-2 Trey Tarr 08,10 3-2 Jackson Freeman 08-09 2-2 Andy Pitts 09-10 5-2 Chris Gill 09-10 4-1 Mark Burlee 09-10 1-2 Robert Janis 09-10 5-3 Andy Pitts 09-10 6-2
State Place Winners:
| Albert Guerraty | 96 | 4 |
| Bret Robertson | 96 | 5 |
| Chaffraix Lelong | 96 | 1 |
| Knox Frank | 96 | 4 |
| Kosal Soth | 96 | 4 |
| Wilson Mustian | 96 | 2 |
| Cary Bowmer | 97 | 2 |
| J.D.Patton | 97 | 4 |
| Nick Williamson | 97 | 4 |
| Peter Hicks | 99 | 4 |
| Peter Knowles | 01 | 4 |
| Akel Grantham | 02 | 1 |
| Ian Macdonald | 02 | 2 |
| Michael Copley | 02 | 5 |
| Jimmy Mackey | 03 | 3 |
| Cory Philip | 05 | 6 |
| Jack Zampolin | 05 | 4 |
| Ashton Gilmore | 06 | 1 |
| J.P.Welch | 06 | 5 |
| Nick Molloy | 06 | 6 |
| Travis Hamblin | 06 | 5 |
| Will Moore | 06 | 7 |
| Kevin Issacs | 08 | 1 |
| Kevin Molloy | 08 | 5 |
| Edward Custer | 09 | 7 |
| Ben Thompson | 10 | 3 |
| Brandon Jeske | 10 | 1 |
| Tyler Cornett | 10 | 2 |
| Tyler Spangler | 2007 USA Wrestling Cadet National Greco- 7th Place |
| Tyler Spangler | 2008 USA Wrestling Junior National Greco- 7th Place |
| Brandon Jeske | 2009 USA Wrestling FILA Cadet Greco National Champion |
| Brandon Jeske | 2009 USA Wrestling Cadet National Greco- 3rd Place |
| 2005 | Zach Rolfe |
| Tyler Hamblin | |
| Ashton Gilmore | |
| 2006 | Kevin Donahue |
| 2007 | Tyler Spangler |
| David Wesley | |
| Trey Tarr | |
| Loren Phillps | |
| 2008 | Tyler Spangler |
| 2009 | David Wesley |
| Brandon Jeske | |
| Tyler Cornett | |
*If you have career records of former St. Christopher's wrestlers, please send them to Coach Prebish! Wrestlers listed in BOLD are currently active St. Christopher's wrestlers.
Rank Name Year Wins Losses Draws 1 Zach Rolfe 2006 202 43 2 Hunter MacDonald 2005 184 30 3 Kevin Donahue 2007 170 24 4 Tyler Spangler 2009 169 30 5 Ted Gottwald 2010 161 48 6 Loren Phillips 2010 158 45 7 David Wesley 2011 155 28 8 Brian Herod 2004 154 22 9 Tyler Hamblin 2007 146 28 10 Brandon Nunnally 2005 133 54 11 Joseph Munno 2008 132 40 12 Ryan Robertson 2004 128 33 13 Rennie Merhige 2010 121 29 14 Jackson Freeman 2009 120 45 15 Kirk Adamson 2004 118 41 16 Clarke Gottwald 2008 116 32 Hunter Carpenter 2003 116 35 18 Samuel Redd 2005 115 42 19 Tyler Schmidt 2005 112 20 20 David Schafer 2005 108 28 21 David Schafer 2005 103 28 Lake Taylor 1988 103 19 1 23 Trey Tarr 2011 101 29
| Rank | Name | Year | PCT. |
| 1 | Kevin Donahue | 2007 | 0.876 |
| 2 | Brian Herod | 2004 | 0.875 |
| 3 | Hunter MacDonald | 2005 | 0.859 |
| 4 | Tyler Spangler | 2009 | 0.849 |
| 5 | Tyler Schmidt | 2005 | 0.848 |
| 7 | David Wesley | 2011 | 0.847 |
| 6 | Lake Taylor | 1988 | 0.837 |
| 8 | Tyler Hamblin | 2007 | 0.829 |
| 9 | Zach Rolfe | 2006 | 0.824 |
| 10 | Thomas Hovis | 2006 | 0.820 |
| 11 | Josh Moses | 2006 | 0.813 |
| 15 | Rennie Merhige | 2010 | 0.807 |
| 12 | Jeb Pinkerton | 2003 | 0.807 |
| 13 | Ryan Robertson | 2004 | 0.795 |
| 14 | David Schafer | 2005 | 0.794 |
| 15 | Ashton Gilmore | 2006 | 0.786 |
| 16 | Clarke Gottwald | 2008 | 0.783 |
| 17 | Loren Phillips | 2010 | 0.778 |
| 18 | Trey Tarr | 2011 | 0.777 |
| 19 | Ted Gottwald | 2010 | 0.770 |
| 20 | Hunter Carpenter | 2003 | 0.768 |
| 21 | Joseph Munno | 2008 | 0.767 |
| 22 | Ian Macdonald | 2002 | 0.760 |
| 23 | Craig Philp | 2007 | 0.759 |
| 24 | Kirk Adamson | 2004 | 0.742 |
| 25 | Samuel Redd | 2005 | 0.732 |
| 26 | Jackson Freeman | 2009 | 0.727 |
| 27 | Brandon Nunnally | 2005 | 0.711 |
To be considered for this list, a wrestler must have won at least 40 matches in a given season. Names listed in bold are currently active St. Christopher's wrestlers.
| Name | Wins | Year |
| Tyler Spangler | 54 | 2008 |
| Hunter MacDonald | 51 | 2005 |
| Zach Rolfe | 51 | 2006 |
| Ted Gottwald | 50 | 2009 |
| Hunter MacDonald | 49 | 2004 |
| David Wesley | 49 | 2009 |
| Joseph Munno | 48 | 2007 |
| Thomas Hovis | 46 | 2004 |
| Zach Rolfe | 46 | 2004 |
| Zach Rolfe | 46 | 2005 |
| Tim Rose | 45 | 2005 |
| Ashton Gilmore | 45 | 2006 |
| Kevin Donahue | 45 | 2007 |
| Tyler Spangler | 45 | 2007 |
| Brandon Nunnally | 44 | 2005 |
| Clarke Gottwald | 44 | 2008 |
| David Wesley | 44 | 2008 |
| Tyler Schmidt | 43 | 2003 |
| Brian Herod | 43 | 2004 |
| Kevin Donahue | 43 | 2004 |
| Loren Phillips | 43 | 2007 |
| Jackson Freeman | 43 | 2009 |
| Brian Herod | 42 | 2003 |
| Hunter Carpenter | 42 | 2003 |
| Kevin Donahue | 42 | 2006 |
| Brandon Jeske | 42 | 2010 |
| Brian McGurk | 41 | 2002 |
| Josh Moses | 41 | 2005 |
| Craig Philp | 41 | 2007 |
| Loren Phillips | 41 | 2009 |
| David Schafer | 40 | 2004 |
| Kevin Donahue | 40 | 2005 |
| Samuel Redd | 40 | 2005 |
| Tyler Hamblin | 40 | 2005 |
| Tyler Hamblin | 40 | 2007 |